Friday, October 31, 2008

Unbelievable Discussion

Wow, did we have an unbelievable discussion at school today!?  As a way of saying "Thank You" to all of my Politics and Elections students for the hard work they did on the mock election, I let the students choose today's class activity.  Their choice, to debate the teachers on issues relating to respect and student involvement in school.  My first thought was, naturally, "uh oh." However, after having the students talk-out what they really wanted from this "debate," we came to the conclusion that it would be more of an open-ended discussion with the teachers. We wrote a letter inviting all the teachers to class and gave them a heads-up on the topics of discussion.  Roughly three staff members showed up for the whole discussion and about three to four came and went as they had time.  
During this "conversation," as it came to be called, students and teachers gave their own definitions of what respect was and gave a vision of what that looked like to them.  This opened up to a conversation about language and finally into student involvement in collaboratively designing courses with the teachers.  We had five questions prepared to lead our discussion but with such active involvement we only got to 2.5 of them in an hour.  It was awesome to watch. Teachers and students flowed in and out of the circle when they wished to share and they asked questions of each other in hopes of clarifying statements and finding deeper understanding. When 2:00 (end of the day) hit, on a Friday, four students stayed after and most teachers found themselves in the classroom continuing the conversation for another half-hour.  It was great to see such a healthy and respectful conversation and, from the feedback I received, it was a conversation that both students and teachers would like to see happen again.
The most surprising revelation or bit of information that came out of the conversation for me and my coworkers, was that the students want us to sit down and talk to them, even on break.  I think we all felt this was sacred student time but, armed with this new information, we will now start taking greater steps to bridge the communication gap.  

1 comment:

sschwister said...

Pretty incredible. You did a great job of clarifying purposes and intentions all around and created a safe environment where trust could be built. Did the fact that it was a discussion about respect help structure the conversation in a respectful way---keeping everyone's eye on the ball, so to speak?

Your work and reflections about this class keep suggesting new conections, at least for me. The launch of Pres-elect Obama's Change.gov portal, and the theme of networked engagement that drives it, runs perfectly parallel in my mind to the kind of respectful engagement happening in your classroom. I wonder if (and hope) we'll be seeing more examples like this of frank, respectful conversations about sensitive-but-important topics, both locally and at the national level via Change.gov. Honest listening and respectful questioning like your students and colleagues are modeling seems like a good start.